MENU
Pizza
Made to order every time! We will accommodate half and half pizzas with the higher priced ingredients or specialty pizza cost. No substitutions on specialty pizzas.
Build-Your-Own Pizza
Select Your Size
10" - $12.10
12" - $15.55
14" - $19.15
Choose Your Crust
Thin & Crispy (Our Specialty)
Double Crust (Thick & Crispy)
Gluten Free (10” GF Crust) - add $3.00
PICK YOUR Toppings
10" add $1.80 each | 12" add $2.10 each | 14" add $2.40 each
Choices: Sausage, Shrimp, Onion, Green Olives, Beef, Anchovies, Pepperoncini, Sauerkraut, Pepperoni, Fresh Garlic, Tomatoes, Pineapple, Bacon Bits, Fresh Marinated Spinach, Artichoke Hearts, Green Pepper, Canadian Bacon, Fresh Mushrooms, Black Olives, Roasted Red Pepper, Chicken, Pickles, and Jalapeño.
Double IT UP!
Double Crust - 10" add $1.80 | 12" add $2.10 | 14" add $2.40
Double Cheese - 10" add $2.10 | 12" add $2.40 | 14" add $2.60
SPECIALTY Pizzas
PAGLIAI'S SPECIAL
Sausage, green pepper, onion.
10” - $15.35
12” - $19.85
14” - $23.95
Vegetarian
Marinated spinach, onion, green pepper, mushroom, tomatoes, light cheese.
10” - $17.35
12” - $21.95
14” - $26.25
House Special
Sausage, beef, pepperoni, onion, green pepper, mushroom.
10” - $19.15
12” - $24.05
14” - $28.70
Taco Pizza
Beef, onion, taco chips, sour cream, lettuce, cheddar cheese.
10” - $19.15
12” - $24.05
14” - $28.70
Margherita Pesto
Pesto sauce, tomatoes, feta cheese, artichokes.
10” - $19.15
12” - $24.05
14” - $28.70
Shrimp Alfredo
Alfredo sauce, shrimp, onion, bacon, three cheeses.
10” - $19.15
12” - $24.05
14” - $28.70
Pepperoni Pesto
Pesto sauce, pepperoni, tomatoes, black olives, onion, feta cheese, pepperoncini.
10” - $19.15
12” - $24.05
14” - $28.70
Bacon Cheeseburger
Beef, red onion, bacon, pickles, cheddar cheese, pizza sauce.
10” - $19.15
12” - $24.05
14” - $28.70
Cara Special
Sausage, pepperoni, Canadian bacon, onion, double cheese.
10” - $19.15
12” - $24.05
14” - $28.70
Starters & Salads
Let's get it started!
Garlic Bread
Thick slice of Country Italian bread toasted with garlic butter by the slice.
$0.89
Cheese Bread
Thick slice of Country Italian bread toasted with garlic butter and mozzarella cheese by the slice.
$1.95
PAGLIAI'S BRUSCHETTA
Country Italian bread, sliced thick topped with our own seasoned tomatoes, slightly toasted, topped with parmesan cheese by the slice.
$1.95
Bread Sticks
Basket of five oven-baked bread sticks served with made-from-scratch meat sauce.
$6.00
Italian Meatballs
Two homemade meatballs covered with your choice of meat sauce or marinara.
$4.75
Tossed Salad
Mixed greens garnished with red cabbage, carrots, cherry tomato, red onion, and croutons with your choice of dressing.
$4.75
Additional dressing - $1.30
Chicken BLT Salad
Mixed greens garnished with bacon, cheddar cheese, chicken, and raspberry vinaigrette or your choice of dressings.
$11.00
Side of Ranch, Meat Sauce or Marinara
Savory homemade dressing and sauces perfect for dipping.
$1.50
Bottle of Ranch
$6.25
Sandwiches
Served with chips and a pickle.
PAG'S Hero
Cured ham, capocolla, salami, pepperoni, and sliced provolone on a hoagie bun with shredded lettuce and “hero” sauce.
$12.00
Italian Meatball
Savory homemade meatballs topped with zesty marinara sauce and provolone on a hoagie bun.
$12.00
Italian Steak
Marinated beef strips with onions, roasted sweet peppers, mushrooms, and provolone on a toasted hoagie bun.
$12.00
Ham & Cheese
Cured ham with provolone cheese on a hoagie bun.
$11.75
Pasta
Served with two pieces of garlic bread and a salad.
Spaghetti
Traditional pasta topped with your choice of meat sauce or marinara sauce.
$15.25
Add two meatballs - $3.50
Lasagna
Layers of pasta with ricotta, mozzarella, and meat sauce.
$15.75
Fettuccine Alfredo
Wide noodles in a creamy white sauce.
$15.75
Add chicken or shrimp - $3.50
Cheese Ravioli
Cheese-stuffed ravioli with your choice of meat sauce, marinara, pesto, or alfredo sauce.
$15.00
Baked Cavatappi
A combination of meat sauce and melted mozzarella cheese.
$15.75
Beverages
Pagliai's Wine Cellar
Glass: $7.00
Bottle: $23.00
White Wines
Pinot Grigio, Chardonnay
Red Wines
Merlot, Cabernet Sauvignon
Sweeter Wines
White Zinfandel, Lambrusco, Moscato
Beer
Bottle: Domestic - $4.50 | Craft - $6.00
Pitcher (on tap): Domestic - $15 | Craft - $16
Pint Glass (on tap): Domestic - $4.50 | Craft - $6.00
Seltzer
$6.00
Soda Fountain
Children’s Take Home Cup - $2.50
Endless Glass - $3.25
Pepsi, Cherry Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mountain Dew, Diet Mountain Dew, Mug Root Beer, Lemonade, Starry, Raspberry Tea
Coffee, Tea & Milk
Fresh Brewed Iced Tea - $2.90
Hot Tea - $2.90
Milk - 2% White or Chocolate - $2.90
Fresh Ground Coffee - $2.90
Dessert
Char's Champagne Cake
Charmaine’s famous champagne cake has been in our family for over three generations.
$5.25
Kids Menu
American Style Ham & Cheese Sandwich
$5.50
Baked Cavatappi
$5.50
Fluffy Ravioli Pasta Pockets Stuffed with Cheese
$5.50
Traditional Spaghetti with Marinara or Meat Sauce
$5.50
Add Meat Ball - $1.85
Naked Spaghetti
$4.25
Pint-Size Pizza Single Topping
$6.30
Kid's Drink & Take Home Cup
$2.50
Catering Menu
Let us handle the cooking for your next gathering! See our menu items below and contact us today to place your order. We'll even deliver and set up.
Pasta Pans
Large pans - serves 20-30 people
Small pans - serves 8-10 people
Salad and bread included. Choose from: Cavatappi, Lasagna, Ravioli, Fettucine Alfredo (add Shrimp or Chicken), and Spaghetti
Salad
Cheese bread
Breadsticks
Sandwiches
Chips and a pickle included. Choose from: Pag's Hero, Italian Meatball, and Ham & Cheese
Pizza
champagne cake HALF SHEET